It's impossible to set the filters correctly for variability between years. It's basically an average. However, eBird users, when confronted with flagged species, need to step up their game and put in comments about how they arrived at the identification or high count. Comments such as "seen well" don't give reviewers any basis for validating a report and it just makes more work when they have to send a request for information. Field submissions using smart phones often don't have notes, which is fine, but when you get home, please amend your submission!
�
Tyler Bell
<jtylerbell...>
California, Maryland
________________________________
From: Jim Moore <epiphenomenon9...>
To: Maryland & DC Birding <mdbirding...>
Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2013 3:07 PM
Subject: Re: [MDBirding] eBird filter settings and Golden-crowned Kinglet
Good points Matt.� I've been working on some non-Maryland eBird filters recently, and one thing I've realized is that even with the ability to set filters based upon a specific day, rather than the start of the month, they will always be arbitrary to some extent.� You have to pick a single day as a dividing line between records that need confirmation and records that do not � there is no middle ground.� But bird abundance is seldom like that.� And even when there is a sudden influx of new arrivals, it is unlikely to happen on the same day each year and cannot be reliably predicted in advance.�
So for me, the lesson here is that during a transitional migration period such as April, one should expect a handful of eBird filter anomalies--either birds that don't need to be confirmed or some that should.� But this may not mean the filters need to be adjusted--it may just be the nature of an imperfect process.
Good birding!
Jim Moore
Rockville
On Tue, Apr 16, 2013 at 11:40 AM, Matt Hafner <hafner.matt...> wrote:
I've seen a lot of comments in recent eBird reports that many people are surprised that Golden-crowned Kinglets are being flagged right now in many counties.� Several of us eBird reviewers were surprised as well, so we looked at the data.
>
>First, you may recall that in previous years, the end of April was a mess with eBird rare bird alerts.� We had to set filters based on calendar month, so the filter developers had to make a choice: Allow Acadian Flycathers to be reported on April 1 or make everyone click "rare species" at the end of April to report them.� Fortunately, this is no longer an issue and we can set filters by day.�
>
>Last August, eBird developed new filters statewide based on data submitted to eBird.� This wasn't perfect and some of those have been edited, and a few still need to be edited.� Sometimes it's difficult for us to notice a filter issue until we see a species pop up repeatedly on the Rare Bird Alert.� This was the case with Pectoral Sandpiper this year, it's a regular March migrant and was getting flagged everywhere!
>
>Back to Golden-crowned Kinglet.� This species really is having an above average April in MD.� http://tinyurl.com/d3ensty� The filters are set to flag them on either the 14th or 15 April all over the state (except Garrett where they breed) which, looking at the data, seems about right.�
>
>So while the filter may seem off for this year, "I'm seeing Golden-crowned Kinglets everywhere, why are they flagged!", the filter is set for an average year for the species. Right now, it's not feasible for us to adjust the filters every year for different species depending on local abundance.�
>
>Please bear with us as we try to set the filters properly over all of Maryland and know that things will only get better as time goes on.� You can email any and all filter comments, questions, and suggestions to me.�
>
>And enjoy all these mid-April Golden-crowned Kinglets!
>
>Good eBirding!
>
>Matt Hafner
>Forest Hill, MD
>
>
>
> --
>-- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Group 'Maryland & DC Birding'.
>To view group guidelines or change email preferences, visit this group on the web at http://www.mdbirding.com
>Posts can be sent to the group by sending an email to <mdbirding...>
>�
>�
>
--
-- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Group 'Maryland & DC Birding'.
To view group guidelines or change email preferences, visit this group on the web at http://www.mdbirding.com
Posts can be sent to the group by sending an email to <mdbirding...>
--
-- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Group 'Maryland & DC Birding'.
To view group guidelines or change email preferences, visit this group on the web at http://www.mdbirding.com
Posts can be sent to the group by sending an email to <mdbirding...>
|