Norm, Comments ARE desired, at least by me. The day I saw this bird I stated that I would not check it off on my life list until a decision was rendered by the MD/DC Records Committee. After thinking about it, and even before the Ring- billed controversy came to light, I came to the decision that even if accepted by the committee, I may not check it off because of my personal doubts. That in no way means I disrespect the decision of the MD Records Committee, it just means that my life list is mine and not the MD Records Committee's. Anyway, I vote to keep the comments and opinions coming and let the feathers fall where they may. Paula Ecker Columbia, MD Paulae2156@aol.com