Message:

[

Previous   Next

]

By Topic:

[

Previous   Next

]

Subject:

Re: Common Grackles (Purple race vs. Bronzed race)

From:

Phil Davis

Reply-To:

Phil Davis

Date:

Fri, 30 Dec 2005 02:32:15 -0500

Hi Gene, Marcia, et al.

A good line of questioning ...

FYI. Below is the "Systematics" section from the Birds of North America 
on-line account for Common Grackle. Hope this helps.

Phil


COMMON GRACKLE (Quiscalus quiscula)

GEOGRAPHIC VARIATION
Plumage coloration varies regionally. Breeders west of Appalachians and 
north of s. New England have brassy bronze body and purple glossed tail, 
whereas birds east and south of there have purplish body with green to 
steely blue glossed tail. Birds of extreme southeast (Florida) have green 
backs. Wide zone of intergradation stretching from s. New England to 
Louisiana where intermediates occur. Wing length and body mass decrease 
north to south, whereas bill length and width increase along that cline 
(Huntington 1952, Yang and Selander 1968).


SUBSPECIES
Three subspecies recognized (Am. Ornithol. Union 1957, Blake 1968). The 
basic outline of morphological characters and geographical distribution of 
these forms was a source of confusion for many years and mostly worked out 
by Chapman (e.g., 1892, 1936). Apart from subtle change in bill and wing 
size outlined above, the chief characters separating the subspecies are the 
color of the back, tail, belly, and to lesser extent, head.

Q. q. versicolor Vieillot, 1819. Often called the Bronzed Grackle, this 
race breeds over most of the range of the species north and west of a line 
running from central Louisiana to s. New England along western margin of 
the Appalachians. This race is highly migratory, wintering south to s. 
Texas and east to South Carolina, thus overlapping with the next 2 
subspecies; versicolor also accounts for all records of vagrant Common 
Grackles to the west of the Rocky Mtns. This race is less variable in 
coloration than the next and typically shows a uniformly brassy bronze back 
and belly and purplish tail. The head color is somewhat variable but 
usually blue-green. This race was formerly considered a separate species.

Q. q. quiscula (Linnaeus, 1758). Known as the Florida Grackle, this race is 
essentially resident from se. Louisiana east to se. North Carolina and 
south to s. Florida. The back is typically dark green and the tail 
blue-green; the head is usually purple and the belly purple-blue.

Q. q. stonei Chapman, 1935. Often referred to as the Purple Grackle, the 
distribution of this race is not well-defined but generally given as lying 
between the above 2 races east of the Appalachians from se. New York 
(formerly to sw. Connecticut?) south to central Alabama and west to central 
Louisiana. Back and belly typically purple; tail usually blue-green. 
Formerly considered a subspecies of the Florida Grackle when that and the 
Bronzed Grackle were considered separate species. Along the area of contact 
between versicolor and stonei from Louisiana to Connecticut, a narrow band 
of intermediate forms have been designated Q. q. ridgwayi by Chapman. These 
"Ridgway's Grackles" show a strong barred effect on back. These 
intermediates and the status of stonei as a valid subspecies are questioned 
by Huntington (1952).


CITATION:
Peer, B. D., and E. K. Bollinger. 1997. Common Grackle (Quiscalus 
quiscula). In The Birds of North America, No. 271 (A. Poole and F. Gill, 
eds.). The Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia, PA, and The American 
Ornithologists' Union, Washington, D.C.



At 23:58 12/29/2005, Gene Scarpulla wrote:
>On Tuesday, December 27, 2005, Marcia Watson-Whitmyre and I observed four 
>Bronzed Grackles at her feeders most of the day.  This raised a few 
>questions in my mind about the prevalence of Purple versus the 
>northern-migrant Bronzed Grackles that winter in Maryland.
>
>1) Those of you with backyard feeders, which races of grackles do you observe?
>
>2) Those of you that observe large grackle flocks, which races of grackles 
>do you observe and in what ratios?
>
>3) Is the occurrence of Bronzed Grackles more prevalent in specific 
>regions of the state?

==================================
Phil Davis      Davidsonville, Maryland     USA
                 mailto:[log in to unmask]
==================================