From: Paul J. Baicich [mailto:[log in to unmask]] 
Sent: Wednesday, February 04, 2009 9:23 AM
To: Paul J. Baicich
Cc: Wayne Petersen
Subject: Birding Community E-bulletin - February 2009

 


THE BIRDING COMMUNITY E-BULLETIN
            February 2009
 
 
This Birding Community E-bulletin is being distributed to active and
concerned birders, those dedicated to the joys of birding and the protection
of birds and their habitats. You can access an archive of past E-bulletins
on the website of the National Wildlife Refuge Association (NWRA):
http://www.refugenet.org/birding/birding5.html
 
 
RARITY FOCUS
 
An Empidonix flycatcher - originally found on 13 December in Choke Canyon
State Park in McMullen County, Texas - was fairly certainly identified as a
Pine Flycatcher, a species from Mexico on 3 January. This was after
prolonged study, many photographs examined, and responses to taped playback
observed (allowed by park staff). Although this is a species that has long
been expected as a vagrant in the U.S., if accepted, this would be a first
record for the country. 
 
Shortly after its appearance was made public, the word spread and birders
began to gather. The bird and birders appeared on TV and in the press, and
by 9 January, birders from at least 26 states had already come to see the
bird. Visitors were thoughtful and courteous, and all remained quietly on
the trail frequented by the bird. 
 
This does not mean that the bird did not create some serious controversy.
Flycatchers in the genus Empidonax are notorious for their identification
complexity, and there were other Empids in the area that added to the
confusion and the debate.
 
The flycatcher in question had tones of yellow-green below, a
tear-drop-shaped eye-ring, an inflected "whit" call, and a peaked crown.
These marks tended to point toward a Pine Flycatcher, but other features,
including its short wing-length, short tail, and somewhat blunt bill in
addition to the presence of two or three additional Empidonax flycatchers in
the area, tended to complicate matters. Specifically, some of the
photographs taken at the park closely resembled a Least Flycatcher, another
Empid that was on site.
 
This flycatcher scenario is a perfect lesson to keep in mind when
considering the identification of a difficult species. Birders are reminded
that they should always keep an open mind, and that notes, photos, videos,
and audio recordings should be carefully contributed to the proper rare-bird
record committees for ultimate evaluation.
 
A collection of notes, photos, audio clips, and other valuable material on
this Empid has been collected by Martin Reid, and can be found on his
website at: 
http://www.martinreid.com/Main%20website/empidchoke.html
And there is a collection of Empid spectrograms, assembled by Chris Benesh,
here:
http://chrisbenesh.com/Chris_Benesh_Site/Choke_Canyon_Flycatcher.html
 
As of the end of January, the bird was still present, and its identity -
Pine Flycatcher or not - remains a mystery.
 
 
RARITY BACK-UP: IVORY GULL
 
If you're not fully satisfied with the possible Pine Flycatcher described
above as our rarity-of-the-month, we suggest a flashy alternate possibility:
Ivory Gull. This gull is a rare Arctic visitor, usually spending the entire
year at or near pack ice.
 
On 17 January Jeremiah Trimble found a stunning adult Ivory Gull on the Dog
Bar jetty at Eastern Point, East Gloucester, Massachusetts. Initially the
gull was very accommodating, alternately perching atop the Dog Bar jetty and
foraging in flight over the cove adjacent to the parking lot. On subsequent
days it was reported at other locations around Gloucester, including the
Jodrey Fish Pier in inner Gloucester Harbor.
 
It has been over 20 years since the last Ivory Gull (an immature bird) was
found in Massachusetts. Hundreds of birders from many states made the
pilgrimage to Gloucester to see the gull.
 
For more details and photos of the Gloucester Ivory Gull taken by Phil
Brown, see:
http://www.nebirdsplus.org/IvoryGull.htm
 
The Ivory Gull in Gloucester was last seen on 22 January; however, amazingly
on 20 January another adult Ivory Gull was found in Plymouth (Massachusetts)
Harbor by Barry Burden. 
 
The Plymouth Ivory Gull continued to be seen until 30 January, where it was
abundantly photographed and pleased countless observers from far and wide.
For photos taken by Shawn Carey, see:
http://shawncarey.zenfolio.com/p925380799
 
There were additional reports of Ivory Gulls elsewhere in January, including
Atlantic Canada, where up to 17 birds were counted in Newfoundland and
others were sighted in Nova Scotia. 
 
As previously noted in the E-bulletin, the Ivory Gull is a species in
considerable trouble. Among other things, it is listed as a species of
special concern under the Canadian Species at Risk Act (SARA). We drew
attention to this situation in the March 2007 E-bulletin:
http://www.refugenet.org/birding/marSBC07.html#TOC05
 
 
U.S. AIRCRAFT-BIRD STRIKES: COMMON BUT RARELY DEADLY
 
After a US Airways jet made an extraordinary emergency landing in the Hudson
River on 15 January, there was much discussion over the role that birds may
play in such incidents. Engine ingestion of Canada Geese was apparently
responsible for this most recent dramatic NYC incident. (The reported
"discovery" of feather and organic material, called "snarge," from Canada
Geese was premature, but a bird strike with the geese is still assumed to be
the cause of the event.)
 
Bird strikes are not uncommon and cost the airline industry millions of
dollars a year, but a dual engine flameout, as experienced over NYC, is very
unusual. 
 
Between 1990 and 2007, civilian pilots reported 79,972 bird strikes to the
Federal Aviation Administration. About 85% of these came from commercial
airlines and the rest involved business, private, or government aircraft.
Strikes are most common between July and October. Almost 14% of these
strikes involve engines. Eight strikes resulted in a total of 11 deaths.
Globally, bird strikes have reportedly killed more than 220 people and
destroyed more than 200 aircraft since 1988. 
 
The collisions often occur at low altitude during takeoffs, climbs, and
landings. For example, on 29 November 2007, a Western Grebe struck the No. 2
engine of a Boeing 757-200 as it climbed to 1,000 feet after takeoff from
Los Angeles International Airport. The plane returned to LAX and made an
emergency landing. The bird damaged 13 fan blades, which cost more than $1
million to repair. In another case, in December 2006, a Great Blue Heron was
drawn into the engine of a Boeing 767 jet shortly after takeoff at JFK
Airport in New York. The plane returned to the airport.
 
NYC airspace, however, seems to be known for its flocks of Canada Geese.
There have been at least eight major strikes between geese and planes
departing or landing at New York area airports since 1995.
 
The primary bird threats near airports can come from waterfowl, gulls,
crows, pigeons, and starlings (in flocks), depending on the habitat and
species present. Some of the common individual strikes still tend to involve
smaller birds, such as Mourning Doves or Horned Larks.
 
Final thought on the issue: Did the geese hit the U.S. Airways plane (the
usual and understandable media approach), or did the plane hit the geese?
 
 
DARWIN BICENTENNIAL
 
This year marks the 200th anniversary of Charles Darwin's birth - 12
February 1809.
 
Darwin is famous for describing in rigorous detail that species change from
common ancestors over time through the process of natural selection. Natural
selection came to be widely seen as the primary - although not exclusive -
explanation of biological evolution and forms the basis of modern
evolutionary theory today.
 
The Darwin bicentennial will be recognized across the globe. Those of us
interested in birds should note that Darwin dealt with birds many times
throughout his scientific career, from early and amateur inquiries into Rock
Pigeons to the puzzle of Galapagos finches. November of this year will also
mark the 150th anniversary of Darwin's seminal publication, THE ORIGIN OF
SPECIES.
 
 
BOOK NOTES: STREET PIGEONS
 
Last month, we drew your attention to a serious and scientific compendium of
information on the birdlife of the Aleutians. This month, we spotlight a
very different sort of bird book - a well-written, short, and breezy volume
on the life of Rock Pigeons and their lives with us. Courtney Humphries,
author of SUPERDOVE (Smithsonian Books, 2008), traces the interaction of
pigeons and humans dating back to when Rock Pigeons were domesticated
(sometime around 3000 B.C.), through the species' incorporation in European
manor and village living, their arrival in the Americas, and their spread
around the world. We learn about Darwin's interest in the species, the
original reasons for domestication (i.e., show, meat, and performance), and
most importantly, how humans have shaped the species and have responded to
the ubiquitous "street pigeon," both favorably and unfavorably through the
years. It is an enjoyable and thoughtfully done read. Humphries is a young
author who should surely be watched. 
 
 
TIP OF THE MONTH: DRINK UP!
 
When you go afield with binoculars, field guide, spotting scope, and camera
you may often use a daypack and bring along all sorts of additional items,
ranging from extra warm gloves to sunscreen, depending on conditions and the
season. But don't forget water!
 
Whether birding in hot or cold conditions, try to drink at least six to
eight glasses of water a day, or even more when hiking or birding in harsh
environments. Without adequate water you body gradually loses its ability to
function properly; it becomes unable to cool down when conditions cause its
temperature to rise, and it becomes unable to generate heat when conditions
cause its temperature to drop.
 
Most fluids can quench thirst, but coffee, although a wonderful beverage
(especially when shade-grown!), is also a mild diuretic, prompting frequent
urination. Be ready to replenish your body's water.
 
Drink up!
 
But while you're at it, also consider addressing the bottled water habit.
Your two E-bulletin editors are old enough to remember when people commonly
carried canteens and thermoses instead of pre-bottled water. Today, when it
comes to water, consider going with a "do-it-yourself" kit - a refillable
and reusable steel (not plastic) bottle and the use of the spigot at your
kitchen sink. Rediscovering tap water is a lot cheaper and a lot better for
the environment than manufacturing, shipping, and discarding all those
plastic single-use bottles. (For example, according to one estimate, the
recent annual production of plastic bottles for water in the U.S. required
the energy equivalent of over 17 million barrels of oil.) 
 
For five good reasons to break the bottled water habit, whether birding of
not, see here:
http://www.newdream.org/water/reasons.php
 
 
IBA NEWS: WILDERNESS ADVANCE; IZEMBEK LOSS
 
In early January, the Senate passed a sweeping public lands bill, including
many new Wilderness designations, called the Omnibus Public Lands Management
Act. This was a mega-package containing 160 proposals in all. It set aside
more than 2 million acres as protected Wilderness in nine states, the
largest expansion of the National Wilderness Preservation System in 15
years. It is designed to safeguard over 270,000 acres along more than 1,000
miles of rivers in Oregon, California, Idaho, Arizona, Wyoming, and
Massachusetts along with adding 2,800 miles of new trails to the federal
system. This single element gives legal permanence to the first new system
of conservation lands in the United States in more than 50 years under the
National Landscape Conservation System Act. 
 
The bipartisan legislation was much-praised, and it passed 73-21 in the
Senate. Comparable approval is expected shortly in the House of
Representatives.
 
Among the lands affected were a number of Important Bird Areas (IBAs), such
as portions of Mount Hood in Oregon, Sequoia and Kings Canyon National Parks
in California, Rocky Mountain Park in Colorado, Jefferson National Forest in
Virginia, and Monongahela National Forest in West Virginia. With each
example, the Omnibus Public Lands Management Act will deepen and enhance the
protection of these IBAs. 
 
Alongside this wilderness protection, however, was a highly disappointing
provision. This provision would allow the state of Alaska to build an
airport access road through a wilderness section of the Izembek National
Wildlife Refuge, an IBA and also a RAMSAR site on the Alaska Peninsula. The
construction of this road could adversely affect internationally significant
wetlands and vital habitat for hundreds of thousands of migrating birds,
particularly Emperor Geese and "Pacific Black" Brant (which gorge on the eel
grass each fall before continuing their lengthy migrations). In exchange for
the road, the state and other landowners would transfer more than 61,000
acres to the federal government, including about 43,000 acres that would be
designated as wilderness.
 
The land swap would give the state a seven-mile easement through the refuge.
The easement would let the state complete a 25-mile gravel road linking King
Cove, with a population of 800, to Cold Bay, population 80, where there is
an all-weather airport.
 
The airport access road "won't work as advertised and won't save lives. The
only way it makes any sense at all is if you tie it to oil and gas
development," said Evan Hirsche, president of the National Wildlife Refuge
Association. The Izembek refuge abuts the North Aleutian Basin, one of the
nation's largest untapped petroleum reserves, raising questions about the
actual motives behind building this road.
 
We have covered "The Road to Nowhere" before, most recently in October 2008:
http://www.refugenet.org/birding/octSBC08.html#TOC10
 
For more on the Senate Bill, see the statement by the Wilderness Society:
http://wilderness.org/content/us-senate-passes-huge-public-lands-bill 
 
For additional information about worldwide IBA programs, and those across
the U.S., check the National Audubon Society's Important Bird Area program
web site at: 
http://www.audubon.org/bird/iba/
 
 
DISORIENTED BROWN PELICANS IN CALIFORNIA AND BEYOND
 
Brown Pelicans along the West Coast have recently been found on highways,
runways, farm fields, and in suburban backyards. The birds share symptoms of
disorientation, extreme fatigue, and even bruising inside their mouths. The
phenomenon - starting in California, but reported south to Baja California
and north to Washington State - is confounding volunteer rehabilitators and
experts alike. 
 
It is not that uncommon at this time of year to have a die-off of some young
Brown Pelicans. What is being reported, however, is a larger than normal
die-off of adults. 
 
One of the most common conditions being observed is disorientation - birds
landing inland, being found in neighborhoods, on roads, runways, etc. This
disorientation implies that something is neurologically wrong with the
birds. In fact, a few of the pelicans have tested for the presence of domoic
acid. Domoic acid results from an extreme proliferation, or bloom, of marine
algae. It can affect the brain, causing seizures in flight where the birds
literally fall from the sky. Due to the broad distribution of ailing
pelicans, and the fact that most of the pelicans are thin, it is unlikely
that this event is caused by domoic acid. When affected by domoic acid,
birds are usually of sound body weight, and it is therefore likely that
demoic acid is playing only a secondary role to what is probably a larger
problem.
 
The enigma continues.
 
For more information, see: 
http://www3.signonsandiego.com/stories/2009/jan/08/1m8pelicans23939-rescue-o
peration/?zIndex=33646
and
http://www.ibrrc.org/pdfs/pr_01_06_2009.pdf
 
 
CONDOR CHICKS IN CALIFORNIA
 
Seven wild California Condor chicks left their nests in California in 2008,
an event which marked a successful breeding season. We neglected to mention
this achievement in our report last month on breeding success for condors in
the Grand Canyon:
http://www.refugenet.org/birding/janSBC09.html#TOC02
 
The addition of these seven young California Condors brings the number in
California to more than 80 free-flying birds in the wild. For more
information on these California Condor developments, see:
http://www.fws.gov/news/NewsReleases/showNews.cfm?newsId=47108004-F5F1-6A82-
E0E70AF5FF07D0E2
 
 
ESA EXPERT CONSULTATION 
 
As mentioned last month, the Bush Administration in its closing months of
office announced a final rule change that weakens implementation of the
Endangered Species Act. At issue were Section 7 consultations with
endangered species experts at the Fish and Wildlife Service and National
Marine Fisheries Service. We pointed out that the incoming Obama
Administration had indicated that it would move to reverse the rule,
although it might take time to undo the change:
http://www.refugenet.org/birding/janSBC09.htbml#TOC04
 
Indeed, in the very first full day of the Obama Administration, a number of
environmental moves attempted by the outgoing Bush Administration were
blocked. Still, the new administration couldn't stop rules that first were
published in the Federal Register and that had cleared a statutory waiting
period before taking effect, such as the rule that allows federal agencies
to forgo expert advice on whether proposed projects would affect endangered
species. 
 
The Obama Administration could launch a new rule-making process to
eventually supplant any of the Bush Administration rules, but that might
take months or years to complete. Congress could also be asked to exercise a
little-used law that would allow it to overturn any of the late Bush
decisions or to prohibit federal agencies from spending money to implement
those rules. Or, the new Administration could drop its opposition to several
environmentalist lawsuits challenging the Bush rules, signaling that the
rules won't stand for long.
 
Options are open, but the direction and intention is clear.
 
 

OSPREY TRAVELS, OSPREY PROBLEMS
 
Among the many radio-tracked birds that we can follow on the Internet have
been 22 Ospreys tagged and monitored since 2004 by Rob Bierregaard and his
colleagues. Originating in the northeastern U.S., these birds have been
followed up and down the East Coast, across the Caribbean, and into the
Orinoco basin of Venezuela and beyond.
 
Unfortunately, some Ospreys never make it back to the U.S. One, "Meadow" by
name, was recently shot (almost certainly) at a farm one mile west of
Higuey, Dominican Republic. This makes four birds lost out of four that
tried to overwinter in the D.R.
 
For details on the researchers and program, see here:
http://www.bioweb.uncc.edu/bierregaard/ospreys.htm
 
Fortunately four birds are still transmitting, two from this year and two
from the class of '07. For a link to the fascinating Osprey satellite
tracking maps, see:
http://www.bioweb.uncc.edu/bierregaard
 
- - - - - - - - -
You can access past E-bulletins on the National Wildlife Refuge Association
(NWRA) website:
http://www.refugenet.org/birding/birding5.html
 
If you wish to distribute all or parts of any of the monthly Birding
Community E-bulletins, we simply request that you mention the source of any
material used. (Include a URL for the E-bulletin archives, if possible.) 
 
If you have any friends or co-workers who want to get onto the monthly
E-bulletin mailing list, have them contact either:
            
            Wayne R. Petersen, Director
            Massachusetts Important Bird Areas (IBA) Program
            Mass Audubon
            718/259-2178
             
                        or
            Paul J. Baicich             
            410/992-9736
             
                                                            
We never lend or sell our E-bulletin recipient list.