Message:

[

Previous   Next

]

By Topic:

[

Previous   Next

]

Subject:

Re: Acadian FC and Soldiers

From:

"David C. Smith"

Reply-To:

David C. Smith

Date:

Sun, 22 Mar 2009 14:01:59 -0400

Agree-- I would not count the bird until I saw it even though I heard what sounded like one because of the time of year. My earliest record at Soldier's is early May. Unless it is seen, I mention it only as food for thought. Birders should recognize the limitations of identification solely by ear, particularly with mimics out there. The burden of proof for such a sighting is much higher. Thanks for pointing that out.

dcs

David C. Smith
----------------------------
        Unless you SEE the acadian these records are questionable and highly 
unlikely.  At McKee-Beshers WMA in Montgomery Co acadians don't arrive until 
late April.
        This is the time of year people start reporting calling wood pewees 
and all they are hearing is STARLINGS giving a good imitation.

Paul Woodward
Fairfax City, VA